Generic XML Differencing Tool | XMLmind Compare Tool | Change Tracking | |
---|---|---|---|
Main function | Show what has been changed. | Show what has been changed. Inserting remarks in XMLmind XML Editor - Online Help in a revision allows to specify by whom, when and why. | Show how changes have been made, by whom, when and possibly why. |
How does it work? | Compare two arbitrary XML files. | Compare two revisions of the same initial document (in which the comparison of revisions has been enabled in XMLmind XML Editor - Online Help). | Record insertions and deletions in the revised document, typically in the form of proprietary processing-instructions. |
Needs to be activated for a given document | No. | Yes. | Yes. |
Performance penalty when loading and saving the document | No. | Not significant. | Possibly yes, when the number of changes becomes large. |
Performance penalty when editing the document | No. | No. | Possibly yes, when the number of changes becomes large. |
Increases the size of the revised document | No. | Yes. The increase in size depends on the number of elements contained in the document. See Section 2, “Elements are given serial numbers”. | Yes. The increase in size depends on the number of changes made to the document. |
Detects all changes | Highly depends on the quality of the underlying algorithm. Yes, for some algorithms. | Yes. | No, cannot handle attributes. |
Allows to accept or reject one or more changes | Yes. | Yes. | Yes. |
Validity of the document after accepting or rejecting one or more changes | Well-formed, may be valid. | Well-formed. In practice, generally valid. | Valid. |
See also: "Approaches to change tracking in XML" by Robin La Fontaine.